One of the most common questions we hear from Super Cub owners is:
“Who is the best insurance company for a Piper PA-18?”
It’s a fair question.
After all, choosing the right aviation insurance company is just as important as choosing the right aircraft.
The challenge is that there isn’t a single insurance company that’s best for every Super Cub owner.
Insurance companies evaluate risk differently.
One company may offer the best rates for an experienced Alaska bush pilot.
Another may be highly competitive for a recreational tailwheel pilot operating from a grass strip.
A third may specialize in heavily modified backcountry aircraft equipped with Bushwheels, floats, or skis.
At BWI Aviation Insurance, we work with many of the leading aviation insurance carriers in the United States and help thousands of aircraft owners compare coverage options every year.
This guide will help you understand which insurance companies are most active in the Super Cub market and how to determine which carrier may be the best fit for your specific operation.
Why There Is No Single “Best” Insurance Company
Many aircraft owners assume aviation insurance works like auto insurance.
It doesn’t.
In aviation insurance, pricing and carrier appetite can vary dramatically depending on:
- Tailwheel experience
- Time in make and model
- Backcountry experience
- Float experience
- Ski experience
- Claims history
- Aircraft value
- Operational profile
- Recent flight activity
The same pilot could receive significantly different quotes from multiple carriers.
Likewise, two owners flying nearly identical Super Cubs may find completely different carriers offer the most competitive terms.
This is why comparing multiple insurance companies remains so important.
What Makes A Good Aviation Insurance Company?
When evaluating insurance carriers, price should only be one consideration.
The strongest aviation insurance companies typically offer:
- Financial stability
- Aviation claims experience
- Competitive premiums
- Flexible underwriting
- Strong customer service
- Long-term market commitment
- Fair claims handling
The cheapest quote is not always the best policy.
Coverage quality matters.
Claims handling matters.
Financial strength matters.
Get Your Piper Aircraft Insurance Quote With BWI Today>>
Global Aerospace
Global Aerospace remains one of the largest and most respected aviation insurance companies in the world.
Many Super Cub owners appreciate Global’s:
- Aviation expertise
- Strong financial backing
- Long history in aviation
- Broad underwriting capabilities
Global Aerospace is often competitive for:
- Experienced tailwheel pilots
- Owner-flown aircraft
- Backcountry operators
- Higher-value aircraft
Depending on the risk profile, Global may be one of the strongest options available.
AIG Aerospace
AIG continues to be one of the most recognizable names in aviation insurance.
The company insures a wide variety of owner-flown aircraft.
AIG is frequently competitive for:
- Personal aircraft owners
- Recreational pilots
- Tailwheel operators
- Long-term aircraft owners
Many Super Cub owners find AIG to be a strong option during the quoting process.
Old Republic Aerospace
Old Republic has built a strong reputation within general aviation.
The company often demonstrates strong interest in:
- Owner-flown aircraft
- Experienced pilots
- Well-maintained aircraft
- Lower-risk operations
Old Republic remains one of the most active participants in the tailwheel insurance marketplace.
Starr Aviation
Starr continues to expand its presence in general aviation.
The company often provides competitive options for:
- Tailwheel aircraft
- Backcountry operators
- Pilots with strong training histories
- Modernized aircraft
Many Super Cub owners see Starr as part of the competitive quoting process.
USSIC
United States Specialty Insurance Company (USSIC) remains active in the owner-flown aircraft market.
The company may be competitive for:
- Recreational pilots
- Personal-use aircraft
- Experienced operators
- Lower-risk profiles
Carrier appetite changes over time, but USSIC continues to be an important player within aviation insurance.
IAT Aviation
IAT participates in many segments of the aviation insurance market.
Depending on the pilot profile and aircraft involved, IAT may provide competitive options for Super Cub owners seeking coverage.
AIM
Aviation Insurance Managers (AIM) continues to represent an important underwriting market for many owner-flown aircraft.
Many pilots find AIM particularly competitive depending on:
- Pilot qualifications
- Aircraft value
- Operational profile
- Training history
Beacon Aviation
Beacon remains another important participant in today’s aviation insurance marketplace.
Like all aviation carriers, Beacon’s competitiveness depends heavily on the specific risk being evaluated.
For some Super Cub owners, Beacon may provide one of the strongest options available.
Which Insurance Company Is Best For Backcountry Operators?
This is one of the most common questions among Super Cub owners.
The answer depends heavily on:
- Tailwheel experience
- Backcountry experience
- Claims history
- Aircraft modifications
- Geographic location
The company offering the best pricing for one backcountry operator may not be the most competitive for another.
Which Insurance Company Is Best For Alaska Operators?
Alaska operations often receive different underwriting treatment than similar aircraft operating in the lower 48 states.
Insurance companies may evaluate:
- Alaska flying experience
- Float experience
- Ski experience
- Remote operations
- Seasonal usage
Some carriers are more comfortable with these operations than others.
Comparing multiple markets remains critical.
Which Insurance Company Is Best For Float-Equipped Super Cubs?
Float-equipped aircraft often require specialized underwriting.
Insurance companies frequently evaluate:
- Float experience
- Amphibious experience
- Water operation history
- Training records
The best carrier often depends on the pilot’s qualifications and operational history.
Which Insurance Company Is Best For Modified Super Cubs?
Many PA-18 aircraft have received significant modifications.
Examples include:
- Bushwheels
- STOL kits
- Engine upgrades
- Extended baggage
- Custom avionics
Some carriers actively pursue modified aircraft while others may be more conservative.
Comparing multiple markets becomes increasingly important as aircraft values and capabilities increase.
Why Comparing Quotes Matters
One of the biggest mistakes aircraft owners make is assuming all aviation insurance companies will provide similar pricing.
They won’t.
Different carriers have different appetites for:
- Tailwheel pilots
- Alaska operators
- Float operators
- Ski operators
- Backcountry pilots
- Modified aircraft
- Higher-value aircraft
This creates opportunities.
The carrier offering the best combination of coverage and pricing for one operator may not be the best choice for another.
What The Best Insurance Risks Have In Common
After reviewing thousands of tailwheel insurance policies, the strongest insurance risks often share similar characteristics:
- Significant tailwheel experience
- Significant Super Cub experience
- Backcountry training
- Clean claims histories
- Annual recurrent training
- Strong recent flight activity
- Accurate logbooks
These factors consistently attract stronger carrier interest.
And stronger carrier interest usually leads to better options.
Why Thousands Of Aircraft Owners Trust BWI
BWI Aviation Insurance has helped thousands of aircraft owners secure coverage for their aircraft.
Whether you fly a stock PA-18, a float-equipped aircraft, a ski-equipped aircraft, or a heavily modified backcountry machine, our team understands which carriers are most competitive for different pilot profiles and aircraft configurations.
We work with leading aviation insurance companies and help aircraft owners compare multiple options based on their specific needs.
Final Thoughts
The best insurance company for a Piper PA-18 owner depends on the aircraft, the pilot, and the mission.
There is no single carrier that is always the best choice.
The key is finding the company that views your specific risk profile most favorably.
By comparing multiple aviation insurance markets and understanding how underwriters evaluate risk, you can improve your chances of securing strong coverage, competitive pricing, and long-term protection for your aircraft.
And that’s exactly what an experienced aviation insurance specialist helps you do.
bwifly.com / 800-666-4359
Continue Reading
